\ud83e\udda6AreaOtter

    2026 Best Schools in Sheffield, PA

    Compare by overall rating, test scores, or class size across 12 schools.

    elementary (6)
    middle (2)
    high (4)

    12 schools · Page 1 of 1

    #1
    🦦88

    West Fork High School

    public
    high
    9-12 · 206 students
    MathN/A
    ReadN/A
    SciN/A
    #2
    🦦87

    Sheffield High School

    public
    high
    9-12 · 278 students
    MathN/A
    ReadN/A
    SciN/A
    #3
    🦦81

    Sheffield M/HS

    public
    high
    6-12 · 233 students
    MathN/A
    ReadN/A
    SciN/A
    #4
    🦦75

    West Fork Middle School

    public
    middle
    6-8 · 155 students
    Math74%
    Read82%
    Sci72%
    #5
    🦦63

    Mt Everett Regional

    public
    high
    6-12 · 294 students
    Math34%
    Read30%
    Sci35%
    #6
    🦦56

    Undermountain

    public
    elementary
    -1-5 · 241 students
    Math55%
    Read39%
    Sci51%
    #7
    🦦52

    New Marlborough Central

    public
    elementary
    -1-3 · 66 students
    MathN/A
    ReadN/A
    SciN/A
    #8
    🦦44

    Sheffield Area El Sch

    public
    elementary
    PK-5 · 209 students
    MathN/A
    ReadN/A
    SciN/A
    #9
    🦦37

    WA Threadgill Primary School

    public
    elementary
    -1-2 · 304 students
    MathN/A
    ReadN/A
    SciN/A
    #10
    🦦36

    L E Willson Elementary School

    public
    elementary
    3-6 · 275 students
    Math13%
    Read54%
    Sci26%
    #11
    🦦31

    Sheffield Junior High School

    public
    middle
    7-8 · 186 students
    Math11%
    Read45%
    Sci24%
    #12
    🦦29

    Millers Run School

    public
    elementary
    -1-8 · 136 students
    Math6%
    Read25%
    SciN/A

    Explore More

    Sheffield overview Best elementary schools Best middle schools Best high schools All cities